Uber uber

The Houston Chronicle reports that the City Council has begun taking the steps towards allowing Uber –the decentralized private driver company– to enter the market here in town. The Council shared a study on the continued feasibility of the regulations in place over the taxi industry. Specifically, some of the regulations affecting Uber –which is treated like a limo service– were recommended for the chopping block, specifically those pertaining to minimum fees and waiting periods before rides.

I called Larry Green’s office –the Chair of the Council Transportation Committee– but his Chief of Staff refused to comment. Likewise, I received no comment from the Committee’s Vice-Chair (Jack Christie), Uber or Yellow Cab. Accordingly, I think it is best to tell this story from the beginning.

Taxis are treated like a public utility in Houston, as in most cities. This means that typical contentions about capitalism and the free market may be ignored. It also means there are countless byzantine regulations over the taxis, although most are actually both logical and needed. As a result of these realities, not only is there very little wiggle room as to how a Taxi company may distinguish itself from others, most are actually aligned under a conglomeration known as the Greater Houston Transportation Company.

Make no mistake, this is not a fight between David and Goliath. Uber is not the dark horse, the underdog or the oppressed small business. Uber is the bandit. There are no barriers to entry in the Taxi industry, although its heavy regulation may make it an unappealing sector to make business in. But with Uber, or other ridesharing apps such as Lyft, truly wish to enter the market, they should play be the same rules.

As Brains & Eggs has noted, Uber has a history of openly flaunting regulations or rules when they don’t get their way, then accusing the law enforcers of some sort of favoritism or bullying. Meanwhile, when things do go wrong, they will be the last to ever take responsibility. You see, Uber prides itself on not being a transportation company, per se, but rather a technology app that simply provides a common software to a bunch of independent contractors.

The regulations Uber finds so tedious are primarily those that heavily regulate employment of drivers and provide for fixed fares. Uber wants neither of these to apply for them, ostensibly because of the aforementioned regulation flaunting. They have a history of insufficiently regulated drivers, sometimes even with criminal histories. Perhaps most importantly, Uber has a history of what hiking fares at inopportune times, which should be described for what it is…price gouging. They call this “surge pricing,” which means, be it a holiday, major event or natural disaster, they significantly raise their prices. The pernicious other side of deregulated, free market pricing is that sometimes the market screws you over, so to speak.

The Washington City Paper recently coined the term “Ubertarian,” as those otherwise left of center individuals who bemoan all government regulations if it dare affect their daily lives. Indeed, Uber is the best example of this phenomenon, with so many otherwise liberal people casting aversions on the inefficiency of this public utility. In my opinion, the idea of taxis being a public utility is a fairly well established one, which means it will not always be the most convenient or the cheapest form of travel.

However, contrary to public belief, the taxi industry is not mainly dependent upon intoxicated yuppies finding their ways home from the bar. Rather, its biggest customers are some of the poorer members of society who use taxis for invaluable tasks such as grocery shopping. This is one of the reasons to heavily regulated pricing is so important. We should not jeopardize that because Uber does not want to play by the same rules.

Off the Kuff has more (from a very different point of view).

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Uber uber

  1. UBER is a highly illegal operation everywhere. They have no real insurance and what little they have is only in force when a paying customer is in the back seat. UBER refused to accept liability or responsibility when an UBER driver ran over and killed a six year old girl in San Francisco. UBER does not drug test or fingerprint their drivers. Some are known felons. UBER exploits their drivers and fires them if they dare speak up. They also overlaod an area with too many cars. UBER even brags on their website (Investors Blog) that they choose new areas where they perceive there is little or no enforcement of transportation laws and regulations. They have also been known to heavily bribe local and state politicians and that is how they are able to get away with this charade. S omebody needs to jerk UBER’s leash back.

  2. Chicago Taxi companies and drivers sued the city Thursday saying rival services like Uber undercut their business while not complying with city laws.

    Attorney Michael Shakman filed the federal suit in U.S. District Court on behalf of taxi firms including Yellow Cab and taxi drivers such as Francis Koblah, a day after the City Council received competing proposals on the burgeoning ride-sharing industry.

    The suit accuses the city of not enforcing its own laws on taxi services and says rivals like Uber, Lyft and Sidecar are undercutting the conventional cab industry as they are not compelled to operate under the same rules.

    http://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20140206/downtown/taxi-lawsuit-targets-uber-lyft-for-unfair-practices

  3. Pingback: Texpatriate | Lyft comes to town

  4. Pingback: Texpatriate | Uber enters the market too

  5. Pingback: Texpatriate | What have I missed at City Hall?

  6. Pingback: Texpatriate | TPA Roundup (March 3, 2014)

  7. Pingback: Texpatriate | Belated council update

  8. Pingback: Texpatriate | Is Uber right-wing?

  9. Pingback: Texoblogosphere: Week of March 3rd | Texas Leftist

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s